People today with little or no musical training somehow “get” a 12-measure blues chorus or the standard song forms of various modern styles. Even music majors taking theory classes have a hard time with sonata form. How is anyone else to understand it?
Sonata form did not always cause confusion or seem to set up a barrier to understanding music. It actual started off as an attempt to simplify music. I have written several posts about the rise of the middle class, the popularity of what we call “classical” music, and the aftermath of the French Revolution, which destroyed public concert life in the three major capitals of Europe.
- When “classical” music was “popular”–part 1
- When “classical” music was “popular”–part 2
- An ear for music
- The birth of the popular music industry
- Vienna 1800: signs of the coming distinction between classical and popular music
- Classical music: the birth of an idea
- Popular music: the birth of an idea
During the time described in these articles, everyone knew sonata form as well as we know the forms of todays music. Even people with no musical training could follow it. Even people who enjoyed music only as an amusement and not as an art form could appreciate clever things composers did with it. It was current, not a museum relic.
The principles of sonata form underlie all classical music from early Haydn through Bruckner, and not a small portion since then. How can today’s audiences without musical training make sense of it? Now, when it’s a specialized subject in a music curriculum, people tend to approach it with some trepidation, as if they have to understand this antiquated system in order to enjoy the music.
The listening experience of sonata form
First of all, enjoy the music for its beauty and wide range of emotional expression. Don’t worry about the underlying form. How many people who enjoy blues choruses and Tin Pan Alley standards can explain the difference? How many people who thrill to a great improvisation on either one know or care about the nuts and bolts its structure? Probably not many.
People who don’t understand the structure of music, any music, can enjoy it on a visceral level. In fact, pitiful is the person who gains an intellectual knowledge of music at the cost of losing the ability to enjoy it viscerally.
Nonetheless, I offer this very non-technical, non-academic explanation. If knowledge and technical understanding are not prerequisite to enjoyment, they can certainly enhance it.
Sonata form grew from dance forms. These, in turn, were mostly two part forms, with both parts repeated. The music started out in a particular key. Either by the end of the first part or the beginning of the second part, it moved to another key. It returned to the first key. After all, too long a stretch of music in the same key can get boring.
In music classes, the standard diagram for these short forms is ||: A :||: B :||, where ||: and :|| indicate repeats and A and B represent different music. Sometimes, though, the first part of A returns at the end of B, or graphically, ||: A :||: ba :||. That has a name of course, but if you don’t already know it, there’s no need to learn it.
Conventionally, some dances were presented in pairs, as in two minuets. Both consisted of two two-part forms in contrasting keys, each with the standard repetition of both parts. After the second dance of the pair, in order to get everything back to the same key where it started, the music repeated the first one, usually without the internal repeats and with some kind of embellishment of the tune.
Together, then, these paired dances made up a three-part form (which we can diagram A B A), with both parts being a two part form. Operatic arias, another source of sonata form, exhibited a different kind of three-part form.
The first two parts did not repeat, and they contrasted not only in key, but in mood. At the end of the second part, the singer went back to the beginning and sang the first part, heavily embellished.
This kind of aria gave the singer a chance to show of his or her technical ability and imagination in embellishment. Within the opera, it gave the composer a chance to portray a dramatic situation to the point of painting a character’s mixed emotions about it.
Technical (sort of) information
Sonata form combined aspects of the older dances and arias and built them into something that could last much longer than any previous single movement, and yet maintain unity and coherence.
From dances, sonata form inherited the basic two part structure. Composers quickly abandoned repeating the second part. After Beethoven, very often they no longer repeated the first, either.
The music moved to the new key by the middle of the first part. As in the operatic aria, the new key coincided with a change of mood. A sonata movement therefore becomes a drama in itself. (Although we usually associate sonata form with instrumental music, Mozart used it in many of his operatic arias and ensembles.)
A sonata form may or may not have an introduction. Leaving that aside, the form begins with a recognizable melody called a theme, which might be as long as the entire first part of one of the earlier dances. When it’s finished, the music makes a transition to a new key. Most of the time, but not always, the composer writes a new theme for the new key.
I have implied that there are one or two themes, with transitional music in between. Actually, sometimes the same theme occurs in both keys. Other times, there may be more than one distinctly different theme in each key. This first part, called the exposition, presents the thematic material like characters in a drama.
The drama inherent in sonata form comes not from the contrast of themes, but the contrast of keys. Or, another way to think of it, having left home (the first key) for some other destination (the second key), the music has to return to where it started. But instead of simply moving from one key to another, as in the old dance form, the transitional part has made it a challenge to get there.
Therefore, the second part of our movement does not begin in the first key. It gets there over the course of great difficulty. There is a building up of dramatic tension, as the themes get ripped apart and made to pass through many other keys, without ever finding a place to rest.
Technically, musicians know this section as the development, or working-out section. If we look at sonata form as a journey, the music takes the scenic route from the second key back to the first. If we look at sonata form as a drama, the two characters (thematic ideas) wrestle and contend with each other until they come to a place of rest.
That place of rest, called the recapitulation, is the final return to the first key. Aside from music, we usually say recap nowadays. It has taken so much struggle to get there, the music can’t stop yet.
The audience needs reassurance that it has gotten back home. So, in a borrowing from the three part form, the recap repeats all the thematic material introduced in the exposition–except this time, it doesn’t change keys.
Once the second theme sounds in the first key, the form has finished.
Keeping in mind that the development and recap together constitute the second part of a two part form, it’s pretty easy to see why it wasn’t repeated. Repeating the first part gives the audience a second chance to hear all the important themes. Repeating the second part would only repeat the drama and its resolution.
In case you were wondering why I provided textbook graphs for the two part form after promising not to be academic, we can see sonata form in this one: ||: A :|| ba ||. “A” is the exposition, which is repeated. “B,” divided into “ba,” is the development and recap and is not repeated. Besides omitting the second repeat, then, sonata form is very much like that old dance form where the beginning of the first part returns at the end of the second part.
The composer may or may not tidy things up a bit more with some extra music tied on to the end. It’s called a coda, which is Italian for tail. Beginning with Beethoven, however, the coda didn’t tidy up anything at all. It’s as if the two characters in the drama get to the end of the recap and discover some unfinished business. They get into a fight all over again, and the coda gets as long as either the development or the recap.
Beethoven blurs and breaks sonata form
Up through the middle of Beethoven’s career, the various sections of a sonata form are fairly obvious once you know what to listen for. Beethoven experimented with blurring the boundaries.
Later composers got so good at hiding the joints that sonata form became an unseen structure underpinning whatever appears at the surface. It takes a great bit of painstaking study for even the most proficient musicians to find them.
Therefore, when it comes to nineteenth-century music in particular, hardly anyone in the audience can hear the form. There. I’ve let the secret out. Even professionals can’t always follow the form or don’t always even want to.